#RivetingReviews: John Munch reviews DEFENDING THE MOTHERLAND by Lyuba Vinogradova

A landmass of daunting enormity and a seemingly inexhaustible capacity among both men and women to endure privation have been the foundations of Russia’s defences over the centuries. Women did not just keep the home fires burning; in the Second World War they drove trains and commanded tanks, most notably at Kursk, the greatest tank battle in history. What’s less widely known is that women pilots flew successful combat missions against technically superior Messerschmitts, bombed and strafed German formations around Stalingrad, and formed ground maintenance crews in the first all-women air units in history.

While these might be seen as socially progressive achievements, they weren’t a result of any policy. Rather, brute necessity dictated that every human resource had to be brought to bear to resist the Nazi juggernaut. Subsequent popular ignorance about the wartime aviators is therefore not difficult to understand. Lyuba Vinogradova herself was unaware of the female Soviet wartime pilots, even though she had scrutinised thousands of pages of documents and hundreds of books about the war as a historical researcher.

Why was women’s contribution so undervalued after the war? In large part it resulted from the stultifying lack of transparency in the totalitarian bureaucracy. Only when Mikhail Gorbachev declared glasnost in the 1980s did survivors of the female war in the air come forward publicly with their stories. Several books on the subject appeared in East and West; film productions were also mooted, although most were canned. At least the reality, albeit in outline form, came into sharper public focus.

In Defending the Motherland we have what may be the final chapter in that Second World War genre that intermingles the personal testimony of combatants with the official contemporary record.

Thus, Vinogradova is able to tell us that the nickname the Germans gave to the amazing Soviet aviatrixes in the 588th Night Bomber Regiment was Nachthexen. Their rickety plywood and percale cotton/canvas biplanes, designed in 1928, were totally outclassed by the German warplanes. So when they came in for their bombing runs they would cut their engines, in order to avoid the German defences, the whooshing of their gliding, canvas-covered fuselages suggesting witches on broomsticks. Hence the nickname.

Then there’s the gamine and gorgeous, Lilya Litvyak, who was the top scoring Russian female ace of all time apparently with 12 kills. She was eventually killed in combat in August 1943 two weeks short of her 22nd birthday. She was known as the White Lily of Stalingrad. Significantly, she was Jewish.

We may think we currently live in interesting times; but reading about these women makes one realise we don’t know the half of it.

Vinogradova’s account gains palpably from her contacts with Nikolai Menkov, a mechanic in the 296 Guards Regiment, and Valentina Krasnoshchyokova, an armourer with the 586 Fighter Regiment. The blend of their wartime experiences and Vinogradova’s archival rigour, gives her book its powerful technical and personal authenticity. Her two wartime sources have since died.

The Second World War is one of the most intense and crowded sectors in publishing with some 250,000 books and academic monographs devoted to its every aspect. Future accounts will have to rely either on discoveries of fresh documents or on reinterpretation of the existing record without any fresh insights from those involved. It will be up to academic historians to continue analysis of the war by magisterial strategic interpretation. Such niche studies as this – of the bitter-sweet and sometimes blighted lives of the Soviet women aviators – will slip, along with their protagonists, into history.

Reviewed by John Munch


Defending the Motherland

By Lyuba Vinogradova

Translated from the Russian by Archie Tait

Published by MacLehose Press, April 2016


John Munch started his journalism career as a reporter and editor on the Cambridge News. He then worked successively for the Sheffield Morning Telegraph, The Guardian and the London Evening Standard. In the the 1970s, he lived in Canada and reported for the Toronto Star, before returning to the UK to spend 25 years on the Financial Times.

Read John Munch’s #RivetingReview of MUNCH by Steffen Kverneland

Read John Munch’s #RivetingReview of DIARY OF A BODY by Daniel Pennac

Read John Munch’s #RivetingReview of MESSAGES FROM A LOST WORLD. EUROPE ON THE BRINK by Stefan Zweig

Read John Munch’s #RivetingReview of THE THINGS WE DON’T DO by Andrés Neuman

Category: ReviewsSep 2016


One comment

  1. Sir, I have written two books about the Soviet Airwomen (http://ita.calameo.com/books/0007962970add6f969d44) and I travelled and long researched and interviewed witnesses about the last battle of Lidya Litvyak in the sky of Dmitrievka, Stepanovka, Kozhevnya, near Krasnyy Luch etc (Ukraine) and there is no evidence that she was killed on the 1st of August 1943, on the contrary. Just one question, sir: if she really died there, why her brother decided to change his surname in Kunavin? Why, if she was such an Heroine? Because there was evidence that she survived her crash and was imprisoned and all war prisoners were regarded as traitor by Stalin… Take care.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *